hermes jardin sur le toit opinioni | un jardin apres la mousson

Hermès' "Un Jardin sur le Toit" (A Garden on the Roof) is more than just a fragrance; it's an olfactory journey to a secret garden perched atop the Hermès headquarters in Paris. This vibrant and unconventional scent has garnered considerable attention, sparking passionate opinions from fragrance enthusiasts around the globe. This article delves into the myriad reviews and opinions surrounding "Un Jardin sur le Toit," analyzing its strengths, weaknesses, and how it compares to other fragrances in the Hermès Jardin collection. We'll explore the nuances of its composition, its longevity and sillage, and ultimately, help you determine if this rooftop garden deserves a place in your fragrance collection.

Decoding the Scent Profile: A Green and Fruity Symphony

"Un Jardin sur le Toit" is a creation of Jean-Claude Ellena, the renowned perfumer who masterminded the entire Hermès Jardin collection. Ellena's signature minimalist approach is evident in this fragrance, which focuses on a few key notes to create a distinct and memorable experience. The primary accords are apple, pear, rose, green grass, and compost, creating a unique blend of fruity sweetness, fresh greenness, and earthy undertones.

* Apple and Pear: These fruits provide the initial burst of freshness and sweetness. The apple is crisp and slightly tart, while the pear adds a juicy and mellow sweetness. This combination creates a lively and invigorating opening that is both uplifting and inviting.

* Rose: The rose note in "Un Jardin sur le Toit" is not a heavy or traditional rose. Instead, it's a light, airy, and almost watery rose that blends seamlessly with the other green and fruity notes. It adds a touch of floral elegance without overpowering the overall composition.

* Green Grass: This is a crucial element that defines the character of "Un Jardin sur le Toit." The green grass accord is fresh, vibrant, and slightly bitter, evoking the feeling of a freshly mown lawn on a sunny day. It contributes to the overall green and natural feel of the fragrance.

* Compost: This is arguably the most controversial note in "Un Jardin sur le Toit." The compost accord is subtle but undeniably present, adding an earthy and slightly decaying undertone to the fragrance. While some find this note off-putting, others appreciate its realism and complexity, arguing that it adds depth and character to the overall composition.

Un Jardin sur le Toit: A Review Roundup – The Voices of the Fragrance Community

To truly understand the appeal (or lack thereof) of "Un Jardin sur le Toit," it's essential to examine the diverse opinions of those who have experienced it. Let's delve into a compilation of reviews, categorized by sentiment to provide a comprehensive overview.

Positive Reviews: Capturing the Essence of a Parisian Rooftop Garden

Many reviewers praise "Un Jardin sur le Toit" for its unique and refreshing character. They describe it as a perfect summer fragrance, ideal for daytime wear and casual occasions.

* "A Breath of Fresh Air": Many users describe the fragrance as light, airy, and uplifting. They appreciate its natural and green scent profile, which evokes the feeling of being in a garden.

* "The Perfect Summer Scent": The fragrance's fresh and fruity notes make it a popular choice for warm weather. Reviewers often mention its suitability for picnics, outdoor gatherings, and everyday wear during the summer months.

* "Unique and Memorable": The unusual combination of notes, particularly the apple, pear, and green grass, sets "Un Jardin sur le Toit" apart from other fragrances. Many appreciate its originality and find it to be a distinctive and memorable scent.

* "Subtle and Sophisticated": While the fragrance is fresh and green, it's also perceived as sophisticated and elegant. The rose note adds a touch of floral refinement, while the overall composition is well-balanced and not overly sweet or cloying.hermes jardin sur le toit opinioni

* "Realistic Garden Experience": Some reviewers highlight the realism of the scent, appreciating the way it captures the various smells of a garden, including the fresh grass, ripe fruits, and even the earthy undertones of compost. They find it to be a truly immersive and evocative fragrance.

Negative Reviews: The Compost Controversy and Longevity Concerns

Despite its popularity, "Un Jardin sur le Toit" is not without its detractors. Some reviewers find the fragrance underwhelming, while others are put off by certain notes, particularly the compost accord.

* "The Compost Note is Overpowering": The compost note is the most common complaint among negative reviews. Some find it to be too strong and unpleasant, describing it as smelling like rotting vegetables or manure. This note can be a deal-breaker for those who prefer sweeter or more floral fragrances.

* "Weak Longevity and Sillage": Many reviewers complain about the fragrance's poor longevity and sillage. They find that it fades quickly after application, becoming a skin scent within a few hours. This can be disappointing for those who expect a longer-lasting fragrance.